The new chair of the transport select committee on the challenges ahead.
If Chris Grayling’s re-appointment was intended to project an image of steady continuity, the reality for transport in this Parliament is anything but.
Difficult but necessary decisions have been postponed for two elections. They are now due. Coupled with problems on existing programmes, the challenges facing the Department for Transport are significant.
A decision on runway expansion is now critically overdue. A final vote was expected this summer, but all bets are off while the Parliamentary arithmetic remains so fragile. Any further delays would be deeply damaging for both the UK economy and an aviation industry already beset by uncertainty over the possible loss of international landing rights after Brexit.
HS3 – or Northern Powerhouse Rail – has reached the point where it must make the transition from a drawing room blueprint to a properly defined and funded government-backed plan. Official enthusiasm for Crossrail 2 seems to have waned, despite the critical and growing capacity constraints on the London rail network. Grayling’s support for a diesel car scrappage scheme has raised expectations, but the plan may experience Treasury resistance. And, of course, the legislation to extend HS2 from Birmingham to Manchester and Leeds via the East Midlands is also due in this parliament.
As new programmes begin, existing projects are slowly unwinding. The DfT and Network Rail committed to a multi-billion pound investment programme without a clear understanding of its costs or deliverability. Important investment programmes, such as main line electrification and freight schemes, are now delayed, over budget, and at risk of cancellation. Maintenance work is now being cut back despite serious safety concerns raised by the regulator and rail workers. Highways England’s Road Investment Strategy – which includes the flawed policy of removing the hard shoulder from motorways – looks set to suffer a similar trajectory.
Every region has a long list of promised or half-promised projects, the delivery of which now looks in doubt. In addition, the new Bus Services Act is about to come into contact with reality for the first time, and it is likely that some operators will fight tooth and nail to defend existing, de-regulated structures. And, as Labour’s frontbench has said, a Cycling and Walking Investment Strategy has finally been produced, but there is precious little investment attached, raising serious questions over how the government will meet its target of increasing the share of sustainable transport journeys.
One of the Department for Transport’s most significant tasks has been its management of the rail franchising programme. Political attention has understandably focused on the question of ownership, but the existing franchise model is struggling on its own terms. Operators are exiting the market and the average number of bids is now below the department’s own target for realising value for money. Behind closed doors, it has been acknowledged that the risk of an operator defaulting has risen.
Ministers must make a significant choice. The status quo of direct awards to incumbent operators delivers neither the competition they want nor value for the taxpayer, but the alternative management contract model has failed on such a scale on Southern that it is not a politically viable option. Direct operation, which was successfully employed on East Coast and was championed in the recent Labour manifesto, is probably out of the question under a Conservative administration. And of course, the planned extension of Driver Only Operation – an assumption of future franchise awards – will be more difficult in a hung Parliament, which should lead to a reassessment of the Department’s industrial relations priorities.
Change is needed, but there are dangers associated with the remaining options that need to be taken into account. If a sudden decision was taken to radically change the existing franchise model – such as by auctioning off lucrative intercity access rights, as proposed by the Competition and Markets Authority – then there is a real danger that timetables could become unworkable. The UK’s world class rail supply chain thrives on certainty and contracts without it. With service quality and jobs at stake, effective scrutiny of rail policy will be even more important in this Parliament than in the last.
These are some of the imminent policy decisions facing ministers, but passengers may see things differently. Transport costs are an inflationary pressure on household budgets: regulated rail fares are up by 27 per cent since 2010; bus and air fares have risen by a third.
Proposals from the last parliament to improve travellers’ experiences, from advertising the cheapest available prices at petrol stations to motorway drivers and flexible rail ticketing, are in danger of falling off the agenda. Cuts to bus routes, investment delays arising from Network Rail’s financial difficulties and de-staffing proposals all have a negative effect on disabled passengers. These voices must be represented in the months and years ahead.
With so much going on, it’s welcome that more controversial proposals inherited from the Cameron administration – such as the planned privatisation of the government’s remaining stake in national air traffic control services – look unlikely to be pursued in a hung Parliament. The challenge for backbench scrutiny is to ensure that other important but stalled policy areas, such as updating the antiquated law on taxis and private hire vehicles or level crossing safety, are not left permanently in the ‘too difficult’ box.
As we head into this new and uncertain parliament, the transport agenda is crowded and congested. With no overall majority, effective scrutiny on a cross-party basis has become even more important – but I’m confident that backbenchers can play their part in improving infrastructure and services for passengers, drivers, and all other transport users.
Lilian Greenwood is the Labour MP for Nottingham South, the former shadow transport secretary and the new chair of the transport select committee.
“Difficult decisions are now due”: the transport challenges ahead By Lilian Greenwood The new chair of the transport select committee on the challenges ahead. If Chris Grayling’s re-appointment was...
Today is the 69th anniversary of the day the NHS was created. The provision of free healthcare for all, regardless of the ability to pay is one of Labour’s greatest achievements but after 7 years under Tory-led Governments, the NHS faces some of its toughest times.
Lilian said "I'm continually impressed by the dedication of our NHS staff, who treat people with great care and compassion even when working under intense pressure.
As politicians we need not just to acknowledge the incredible work of our NHS, but also ensure it has the resources it needs now and in the future.
Happy Birthday NHS.
Today is the 69th anniversary of the day the NHS was created. The provision of free healthcare for all, regardless of the ability to pay is one of Labour’s greatest...
Lilian Greenwood MP says “it’s the end of the road for unsafe pavement parking”
Lilian Greenwood MP attended a Guide Dogs event at the House of Commons on 3 July to show their support for the campaign to end problem pavement parking.
At the event, the MP for Nottingham South heard from guide dog owners how parked cars blocking the pavement force them to walk in the road, into the path of traffic they cannot see. They heard that some guide dog owners face these dangerous situations on a daily basis, risking their safety every time they go shopping or make the school run.
Research by YouGov for the charity Guide Dogs shows that 54% of UK drivers admit to parking on the pavement, with more than a quarter (29%) of those doing so a few times a month or more. More than half (55%) of these drivers do think about the impact on people with sight loss, but park on the pavement anyway.
Pavement parking particularly affects people with visual impairments, parents with pushchairs, wheelchair users and other disabled people. According to a Guide Dogs survey, 97% of blind and partially sighted people have encountered obstacles on the pavement, and 9 out of 10 have had problems with pavement parked cars.
Guide Dogs is campaigning for to make pavement parking an offence, except in areas where local authorities grant specific exemptions. This is already the case in London, but elsewhere across the country, councils struggle to tackle unsafe pavement parking because they can only restrict it street by street.
Lilian Greenwood MP commented: " I know from discussions with my own constituents that inconsiderate and dangerous parking is a real problem for blind and partially sighted people, wheelchair users and parents with young children, prams and buggies. No one should be forced to walk in the road by cars parked on the pavement. It's time the Government acted to tackle problem pavement parking across the country."
James White, Senior Campaigns Manager at Guide Dogs, commented: “Pavement parked cars can turn the walk to work or trip to the shops into a dangerous obstacle course. It’s a nuisance for anyone, but if you have a visual impairment or a toddler in tow, stepping out into the road with moving traffic is just too big a risk.
Lilian Greenwood MP says “it’s the end of the road for unsafe pavement parking” Lilian Greenwood MP attended a Guide Dogs event at the House of Commons on 3 July...
Lilian is supporting film-makers from Nottingham South by calling for local creative talent to enter Parliament’s largest creative competition, Film the House.
The competition, now in its sixth year, offers the opportunity to put local film-makers in direct contact with the movers and shakers of the two industries and to have the best of Nottingham South’s talent take front and centre stage. Judged by the leading lights of industry, with prizes ranging from work experience at Sky, mentoring from Lord David Puttnam, advice from screenwriters, a day on a film set and the winners’ films being screened. Film the House competitions are a pioneering opportunity to showcase what Nottingham South has to offer, raising awareness about the importance of Intellectual property (IP) to our creative industries and country.
Lilian said: “I welcome the return of Parliament’s most-hotly contested competition, and would urge all local film-makers to enter Film the House. This is an excellent opportunity for Nottingham South to celebrate our local talent and, as all nominations are judged by industry experts, there is no finer chance for our film-makers to gain exposure.”
Dates for the 2017 competitions are:
31 July 2017: Closing date for entries to MPs’ offices
30 August 2017: Closing date for MPs to announce their nominations/submit their respective shortlists to the final judging panel
24 October 2017: Award Ceremony with screening, House of Commons, London.
More information on how to apply for the competition can be found at: www.filmthehouse.co.uk
Please contact the constituency office on 0115 7711 7000 for further information or: -
Barbara Hayes, Deputy Chief Executive, ALCS
Barbara.firstname.lastname@example.org, 020 7264 5700
Alison Baxter, Head of Communications, ALCS
Alison.email@example.com, 020 7264 5700
Lilian is supporting film-makers from Nottingham South by calling for local creative talent to enter Parliament’s largest creative competition, Film the House. The competition, now in its sixth year, offers... Read more
Parliament now has its highest-ever number of female MPs following the general election. Labour leads the way with a record breaking 119 women MPs now in Westminster. Very proud to be one of them.
Parliament now has its highest-ever number of female MPs following the general election. Labour leads the way with a record breaking 119 women MPs now in Westminster. Very proud to...
Lilian visited the William Woodsend Almshouses on Derby Road Nottingham recently, to see the development of six new properties NCHA has built called William Woodsend Court. The six new properties consist of six one-bedroom flats which are available for affordable rent. They are located around a central tree offering a communal garden area which Lilian fittingly described the site as “an oasis of calm and tranquillity”. During her visit Lilian emphasised the need for more high-quality affordable housing in the local area. She was delighted to see that NCHA had refurbished the existing almshouses and built six new flats on a site that she had once assumed was derelict.
Mike Andrews, Chief Executive at NCHA, said:
“I, and the rest of our Board, were delighted to be able to show Lilian Greenwood the new properties we have built at William Woodsend Court. We remain committed to building new affordable housing to play our part in helping to address the ongoing housing crisis in the UK. It is vital that housing remains high on the agenda for this general election, and beyond, regardless of the outcome."
The visit was part of National Housing Week campaign "Working together for great homes".
Lilian visited the William Woodsend Almshouses on Derby Road Nottingham recently, to see the development of six new properties NCHA has built called William Woodsend Court. The six new properties... Read more
I want to thank you for your tremendous support during the election, whether you voted Labour or not I'm honoured to be re-elected as the MP for Nottingham South with a majority of 15,162.
As I’m sure you know, 30,013 Nottingham South residents voted Labour last Thursday – the highest number of votes cast for Labour in the constituency’s history. We secured 62% of the vote whilst the Tories, Lib Dems, UKIP and Greens all saw their share of the vote fall.
In Parliament the Tories are in chaos and it is Labour's responsibility to hold the Government to account.
As ever, when I stood I promised to be available and accountable to all residents so please do get in touch with me with any concerns, or to discuss policy and any votes in Parliament.
Once again, thank you for your support. I look forward to continuing to represent you in Parliament.
I want to thank you for your tremendous support during the election, whether you voted Labour or not I'm honoured to be re-elected as the MP for Nottingham South with... Read more
I am not currently an MP as Parliament has been dissolved until after the General Election on 8th June 2017.
I am not currently an MP as Parliament has been dissolved until after the General Election on 8th June 2017.
Lilian spent 4 hours tonight on patrol with the Community Protection team covering the Lenton/Derby Road area. Lilian said "It was a real privilege to see the vital work the Community Protection team do to tackle noise, anti-social behaviour and environmental problems in the Lenton triangle and Lenton Drives. My thanks to the team for taking me with them on their shift and highlighting local issues around the area.
Lilian spent 4 hours tonight on patrol with the Community Protection team covering the Lenton/Derby Road area. Lilian said "It was a real privilege to see the vital work the... Read more
On the day that the Prime Minister finally triggered Article 50 Lilian met with the East Midlands Chamber of Commerce and Nottingham Means Business to discuss the Government's Industrial Strategy and the East Midlands response. Lilian said " I found our discussions extremely helpful - enabling me to understand the priorities of local businesses and identify unanswered questions to raise with Ministers in Parliament.
On the day that the Prime Minister finally triggered Article 50 Lilian met with the East Midlands Chamber of Commerce and Nottingham Means Business to discuss the Government's Industrial Strategy...